In the News

March 21, 2022

Looking In On Li-Cycle Holdings

Summary

  • Today, we take our first look at a company called Li-Cycle Holdings in the interesting niche of recycling batteries for the EV industry.
  • Li-Cycle is planning a huge ramp-up of its capacity to support the projected growth of the EV industry.
  • A full investment analysis is provided in the paragraphs below.
  • Looking for a portfolio of ideas like this one? Members of The Busted IPO Forum get exclusive access to our model portfolio. Learn More »

March 16, 2022

Original article published in Seeking Alpha

Today, we take an in-depth look at another EV battery-related concern that has been crushed in the recent sell-off in the market that has seen all high beta sectors pull back severely so far in 2022. Are we near a bottom? We examine that question in the analysis below.

LICY stock chart

Company Overview:

Li-Cycle Holdings (NYSE:LICY) is located in Toronto. The stock currently trades right at $8.50 a share and sports an approximate market capitalization of $1.4 billion.

Li-Cycle supply chain facts

The company provides a mix of cathode and anode battery materials, including lithium, nickel and other battery inputs such as graphite, copper, and aluminum. Li-Cycle is engaged in the lithium-ion battery resource recovery and lithium-ion battery recycling business.

North American Spoke and Hub map

The company primarily recovers the critical materials in lithium-ion batteries. They then can be recycled and reintroduced to the EV cycle chain. The company is in the process of substantially ramping up its ‘black mass’ production capacity. Black mass contains varying amounts of cobalt, lithium, graphite, nickel, copper, and manganese. Two tons of black mass capacity roughly equals one gigawatt (GWh) hours of lithium-ion batteries. Each GWh of lithium-ion batteries is enough to power approximately 1,250 electric vehicles.

The company has a series of spokes or regionally optimized locations to reduce costs and increase safety. Currently, Li-Cycle has approximately 10,000 tons of lithium-ion battery capacity but this will ramp up substantially in coming years. Leadership is targeting an eventual annual Spoke processing capacity of up to 45,000 tons of lithium-ion battery input and Hub processing capacity of 90,000 tons of lithium-ion battery equivalent input in North America.

Li-Cycle global recycling capacity

This expansion will support projected mega-factory production capacity growth which the company estimates ‘will grow from approximately 45 GWh in 2021 to more than 500 GWh by 2025. European mega-factory capacity is also projected to grow from 37 GWh in 2021 to more than 930 GWh by 2030.’

LICY International Spoke expansion - fact sheet

The company is focusing on the North American and European EV markets at the moment but will explore opportunities in Asia as they arise. Its operations in Norway should come online in early 2023.

Li-Cycle European spoke plan

Fourth Quarter Results:

On January 27th, Li-Cycle reported fourth quarter results. It is important for potential investors to remember that the company is in the very early stages of its aggressive built-out strategy. Revenues for the fourth quarter came in at $4.4 million, a huge increase over just $500,000 in sales in 4Q2020. For all of FY2021, the company had $7.4 million of sales compared to just $800,000 in FY2020. Total operating expenses were $18.2 million for the quarter and almost $40 million for FY2021. This is a significant increase over the just less than $10 million of these expenses in FY2020 as the company significantly ramped up operating activities as it builds out its production capacity.

Analyst Commentary & Balance Sheet:

The analyst community has been mixed on Li-Cycle’s prospects so far in 2022. Three analyst firms including Citigroup have reissued Buy ratings on Li-Cycle this year, albeit two of them with downward price target revisions. Their current price target among these bulls is now $11 to $18 per share. Robert W. Baird has maintained their Hold rating and $9 price target, and Morgan Stanley downgraded the shares to Equal Weight with a $10 price target.

Li-Cycle ended FY2021 with just under $600 million in cash and marketable securities on its balance sheet. Leadership listed two key events in the fourth quarter in regards to its balance sheet within the press release that accompanied fourth quarter results.

  • Received $100 million investment from Koch Strategic Platforms in the form of a convertible note; expanding strategic partnership to support the growth of Spoke and Hub network.
  • Progressed proposed arrangements with LG Chem and LG Energy Solution to recycle battery scrap materials and off-take for nickel sulphate; $50 million investment in Li-Cycle upon completing commercial agreements by mid-March.

In addition, in early February, the company redeemed all the outstanding warrants in its stock with a further simplified capital structure.

Verdict:

The current analyst consensus has the company losing between a quarter to 30 cents a share as revenues jump more than fourfold to north of $35 million. The current projections are in wide range of approximately $90 million to $290 million in sales in FY2023 with the company still delivering a manageable loss.

LICY 2025 network targets

Li-Cycle’s balance sheet appears in good shape to support the huge ramp-up of capacity leadership is planning for over the coming years. There are way too many unknowns (pace of EV buildout, metals pricing, projected capacity ramp out meets schedule/budget, etc.) to merit a large stake given Li-Cycle is in the very early innings of its journey. A small ‘watch item‘ holding as a proxy for the predicted migration to electric vehicles doesn’t seem out of line on the recent huge pullback across the space, however. There are options against this equity, so a covered call strategy is viable.